Teaching in a “Post-Truth” World
Critical Media Literacy, Epistemology, and the Secondary English Classroom
Dr. Benjamin N. Lathrop — Assistant Professor of Secondary Education, National Louis University
In an era defined by synthetic media, generative artificial intelligence, and sophisticated ideological echo chambers, secondary students confront an unprecedented deluge of digitized disinformation. Standard “fact-checking” checklist methodologies often prove insufficient in this terrain. My research and practice address this crisis by investigating how teacher candidates and in-service educators integrate critical media epistemology—examining not just *what* is true, but *how* we construct, evaluate, and justify knowledge—into the secondary English Language Arts classroom.
Core Areas of Inquiry
Moving literature curricula past checklist media analysis and into deeper explorations of algorithmic structures, power dynamics, and the cultural construction of belief systems.
Analyzing qualitative classroom case studies—such as teacher candidates managing the emotional friction of “post-truth” political and cultural discourses in localized communities.
Evaluating the pedagogical affordances and critical risks of using Large Language Models like ChatGPT in literacy education, framing tech-critique as a vital literacy skill.
Exploring Classroom Discourse Under Societal Strain
My current IRB-approved study at National Louis University, “Teaching in the ICE Age: The influence of mass deportation on teacher candidates’ curricular and instructional decisions,” investigates how shifting political realities and immigration enforcement policies filter into the language arts classroom, shaping the critical narratives teacher candidates feel equipped—or anxious—to present.
Teaching in a “Post-Truth” World
Critical Media Literacy, Epistemology, and the Secondary English Classroom
Dr. Ben Lathrop
Assistant Professor
National Louis University
National Board Certified Teacher with 18 years of secondary ELA classroom experience. Currently researching critical media literacy, generative AI in education, and media epistemology.
The Crisis of Truth & Media in Literacy Education
In our highly-digitized landscape, students confront an unprecedented deluge of synthetic media, generative AI, sophisticated targeted disinformation campaigns, and ideological filter bubbles. Standard media literacy frameworks often fall short because they check superficial boxes rather than investigating the foundational nature of knowledge itself—epistemology.
01. Critical Media Epistemology
Moving beyond simple “fact-checking” listicles to encourage students to analyze *how* we determine what is true and *whose* interests are served by online algorithms.
02. Practitioner-Inquiry & Case Studies
Investigating active classrooms to see how teacher candidates and in-service teachers navigate the classroom tensions of “post-truth” eras, culture war pressures, and shifting media terrains.
Professional Services
Providing schools, districts, and professional organizations with research-informed guidance to navigate modern educational challenges.
School & District Workshops
Equip ELA and Social Studies departments with classroom-tested methods for teaching critical media literacy and epistemology in politically complex local climates.
AI Pedagogy Consultations
Establish curriculum policies regarding Generative AI, framing technology-critique and “the warm demander” philosophy as crucial literacy skills.
Program Evaluation
Design, implement, and analyze qualitative educational interventions, leveraging practitioner-inquiry methods and robust academic standards.
Recent Research Spotlights
Explore the core theories, empirical findings, and pedagogical takeaways from my three most recently published articles.
Teaching Literature in a Post-Truth World
Authors: Benjamin N. Lathrop, Cindy Aubuchon, Kaylyn Stockdell, and Arden Woodall
In this piece, we outline a structural path forward for high school literature instructors. Instead of segregating “media literacy” into isolated media modules or digital checklists, we argue that teachers must weave critical media epistemology directly into the fabrics of standard literature curricula.
“When we study how classic characters negotiate truth and deceit, we create a safe, historical mirror for students. They can analyze the political structure of truth-making within a novel, preparing them to question the corporate interests and algorithmic networks in their own digital feeds.”
The study introduces **three strategic pathways** for educators to transform traditional literary analysis into active, reflective training spaces for digital media epistemology.
Using complex literary narrative layers to map out real-world corporate gatekeeping, propaganda filters, and narrative framing models.
Ask students: “How does the character validate what they believe is happening? What systems of authority are controlling that information, and how does that match your digital feeds?”
Confronting the Post-Truth Phenomenon
Author: Dr. Benjamin N. Lathrop (Single-Authored Study)
This paper highlights how typical high school media literacy curricula rely too heavily on simplified, logical listicles or commercial checklists (such as CARS or CRAAP tests). I argue these models fail when students face emotionally-charged, hyper-targeted digital algorithms.
“When misinformation is designed to play directly into identity and group-belonging, simple static fact-checking is insufficient. We need to teach media epistemology—empowering students to analyze how consensus is reached, whose political power is being reinforced, and how digital algorithms shape our beliefs.”
The study provides a theoretical framework for building **epistemic cognition skills** inside the English classroom, moving the focus from “checking websites” to investigating the “Constitution of Knowledge.”
Rather than asking if a site is ‘true,’ guide students to map out who funded the narrative, and how algorithms monetize emotional confirmation bias.
Transition from the query “Is this site trustworthy?” to “How does this specific narrative function to consolidate power, and what are the epistemic pathways of its circulation?”
Try This in a Small Town
Authors: Benjamin N. Lathrop and Kaylyn Stockdell
In this empirical research study, we design-tested an inquiry-based Critical Media Literacy (CML) curriculum within an 11th-grade rural English classroom. Focusing on climate change and environmental consumption narratives, we analyzed the digital media habits of rural youth.
“We discovered that students readily accepted commercial online content if it utilized a familiar, local community frame. By guiding them to analyze the environmental impacts of single-use plastics through a critical lens, they began questioning the power dynamics behind localized misinformation networks.”
The findings illustrate the critical importance of localized practitioner collaborations in building critical thinking frameworks that respect, rather than alienate, rural cultural identities.
Understanding the unique information ecosystems of rural communities, where distrust of national corporate media is highly prevalent.
Have students select a local, contentious ecological topic and map out how commercial marketing, localized rumors, and independent scientific data represent it.
Curriculum Vitae
Filter and explore Peer-Reviewed Articles, Grants, Teaching Appointments, and Leadership roles in real time.
Peer-Reviewed Publications & Books
Total Scholarly ImpactTeaching literature in a post-truth world: Three strategies for integrating critical media epistemology into literature curricula.
Changing English. (Co-authored with C. Aubuchon, K. Stockdell, and A. Woodall)
The Manosphere: What educators should know.
The Educational Forum. (Co-authored with B.L. Nash)
Confronting the post-truth phenomenon in literacy education: The need for a critical media epistemology.
Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 68(6), 665-678. (IF: 1.523)
Parents’ rights and the “dangers of critical race theory” for children: More than spots & stripes.
Equity & Excellence in Education, 1-17. (Co-authored, IF: 2.6)
Try this in a small town: Climate change and critical media literacy in a rural high school.
English Journal, 114(2), 86-94. (Co-authored with K. Stockdell)
“I would get canceled for speaking like this”: Balancing justice, compassion, and freedom in the antiracist English methods classroom.
English Education, 56(2), 95-101.
Researchers beware: ChatGPT is a bullshitter.
English Education, 55(3), 219-221. (Co-authored with T.S. Johnson)
“We shall take their children away and rear them to the fatherland”: A discourse analysis of a “parent advocacy” group.
Journal of Language and Literacy Education, 18(2), 1-23. (IF: 1.77)
In conversation about GenAI in ELA education: Initial insights and experiences.
In C.M. Moran (Ed.), Revolutionizing English education: The power of AI in the classroom.
[Review of the book: Teaching Writing in the Age of AI: Strategies for Teachers of Secondary Students]
Inquiry in Education, 18(1).
}Plotting your journey to a PhD.
Indiana Council of Teachers of English.
ChatGPT, writing instruction, and the warm demander.
Indiana Writing Project on Substack.
Grants, Fellowships, and Honors
Funding & HonorsEnglish language teaching at secondary level, phase I/II
American University of the Middle East, Kuwait. Collaborative development.
Integrating critical media literacy into ELA: A multi-site case study
Purdue University College of Education Small Research Grant (Primary proposal writer).
Paul and Kate Farmer English Journal Writing Award
Honorable Mention. National Council of Teachers of English.
Dean’s Doctoral Fellowship
Purdue University. Full PhD funding covering annual stipend and tuition remission.
Harding High School Teacher of the Year
Awarded by peer consensus at Harding High School (SPPS).
Teaching Appointments & Courses
Classroom TimelinesAssistant Professor of Secondary Education
- SEC 512: Methods of Teaching English at the Secondary Level
- EDU 510: History & Philosophy of American Education: Social Justice
- SEC 502: Introduction to Teaching at the Secondary Level
- SEC 590B/581B: Secondary Education Practicum & Student Teaching Seminar (ELA)
Graduate Instructor & Supervisor
Taught literacy methods, middle school reading, community issues courses, and supervised ELA student teachers.
English Language Arts & Journalism Instructor
Instructed ELA Grade 9-10, advanced journalism pipelines, and established the International Baccalaureate (IB) Literature and Performance programs.
University Degrees & Teaching Licensures
Formal QualificationsPh.D. in Curriculum & Instruction (English Education)
Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN
Dissertation: Toward a Critical Media Epistemology: A Practitioner Inquiry-Informed Case Study
Adviser: Tara S. Johnson
M.Ed. in Curriculum & Instruction (English Education)
The University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN
B.A. in English
Grove City College, Grove City, PA
Teaching Licensure & Certificates:
- National Board Certification: Adolescent/Young Adulthood English Language Arts (2018-Present)
- Qualitative Research Certificate: Purdue University (2025)
- Indiana State Teaching License: Language Arts, Grades 5-12 (2021-Present)
Professional Leadership & Community
Boards & Civic ContributionsIndiana Writing Project (IWP)
Serving as an active Teacher Consultant, assisting local teacher communities with critical writing pedagogies (2024-Present).
Indiana Council of Teachers of English (ICTE)
Appointed Membership Director and Recording Secretary, coordinating local and state English education networks (2023-Present).
Local Attica Community Contributions
- Board Secretary & Volunteer: Area Sharing Kindness Food Pantry, Attica, IN (2025-Present)
- Board of Directors: Attica Pickleball Association, Attica, IN (2025-2026)
- Active Member: Rotary Club, Attica, IN (2026-Present)
- Election Clerk: City of Attica, IN (2024)
Critical Epistemology Sandbox
Test any online article, headline, or informational claim using a critical media literacy curriculum logic checklist.
Fill in a test headline/claim and press “Run Scan” to generate critical curriculum diagnostics.